Skip to main content

Mobile Ads

Cruella movie review: Emma Stone tries, but misses the mark

Language: English

The first thing that struck me in Cruella was Emma Stone’s cartoonish accent. In an interview, she said she assumed a Mid-Atlantic accent – one commonly seen in old Hollywood movies, that's neither American nor British – for the role. But Stone's attempt simply does not yield the outcome she and the makers had expected. It's a distraction from completely enjoying the character. The accent in question has a rather cool history, but that’s not really the focal point here.

Emma Stone as Estella. Disney

Cruella, directed by Craig Gillespie, is the origin story of the skunk-haired classic Disney villainess from 101 Dalmations, played by Glenn Close (who is credited as executive producer). Close as Cruella De Vil was hammy, incredibly terrifying, and delightfully diabolical. The character was faithful to the original animated film, unlike this one that takes some revisionist liberties, tries to take the bitter edge off of Cruella by humanising her, and directs the audience to the reasons why she switched to the dark side.

The story begins with a flashback. We meet a young Estella (Tipper Seifert-Cleveland), who dreams of making it big as a fashion designer. As a child, she always stands out in the crowd, because of her differently coloured hair and bullish, outspoken nature. Estella is often bullied, but never buckles down to the horrible kids who just couldn't get themselves to accept her.

Eventually her mother Catherine (Emily Beecham), who only wants Estella to fulfil her passion, pulls her out of school and decides to move to London. In typical, heartbreaking Disney fashion (Bambi, The Lion King), Catherine dies in a freak accident involving ferocious Dalmatians that leaves Estella orphaned.

Paul Walter Hauser, Emma Stone and Joel Fry in Cruella. Twitter

Then begins the adventure; Estella quickly adapts to her circumstances, befriends two street urchins Jasper (Ziggy Gardner then Joel Fry) and Horace (Joseph MacDonald then Paul Walter Hauser). In their 20s the three reside in a derelict building, and make ends meet by pickpocketing and petty thefts. Estella never forgets her designing dream, and makes the most immaculate disguises for their escapades.

Fry and Hauser, who later become Cruella's trusty henchmen, provide the requisite comic relief in an otherwise humourless story, but also serve as a reminder of the goodness she might just leave behind. Hauser's Horace particularly stands out throughout the film, and will remain the only memorable character for me. Him and Artie, the David Bowie-d thrift shop owner, whom Cruella recruits to further her boisterous sartorial plans.

Emma Thompson. Disney

One day Estella lands a job at London’s high-end fashion store, a janitorial position that she’s keen to upturn into a fashion one. Days go by, her manager ignores her pleas and requests. So Estella finally breaks. She rebels, and redoes the store’s display that gets her noticed by the city’s most sought-after couturier, The Baronness (Emma Thompson). The Baronness, emanating strong Miranda Priestly energy, runs her workshop with an invisible whip. Thompson superbly plays this vile, haughty and selfish character, whose word is always the law for those who work under her. Initially, Estella reveres the Baronness, then establishes herself as a rival on equal grounds when she makes a nasty discovery.

A still from Cruella. Disney

Set in the 1970s, Cruella recalls the city at the peak of the punk rock movement that influenced not just music, but also fashion. The clothes, loud, brash, defiant, and  inventive are masterpieces, the pièce de résistance. The late Alexander McQueen seems to be the most heavily referenced here; a sequence also gives the nod to the British designer’s 2001 runway show. I’m not a fashion savant, quite the opposite, but even I can recognise the absolute beauty and the painstaking effort that must have gone into creating these pieces.

Besides the cringey accent, Stone does not make for a very convincing Cruella De Vil. I wanted to feel excited for Estella, when she nabbed the chance to work with the Baroness; I wanted to feel her frustration when she was stuck in a dead-end ob at the Liberty of London; and when she was on this deranged revenge spree, but Stone’s watery performance never fully realises any of these emotions.

The movie is a little over two hours; two hours too long. There's a lot going on. There's a lot to grasp onto, and if you have a short attention span, or if you're watching this movie with a child, it will be a little tough to keep up. The writers, a little too impassioned in their endeavour to give Cruella a colourful backstory, have overstuffed the narrative. The story unfolds similarly to Joker, and will even remind you of The Devil Wears Prada — no surprises there, one of co-writers Aline Brosh McKenna wrote the 2006 comedy-drama.

Cruella is Disney's latest efforts to reintroduce old characters, and contemporise them for the new, younger generation of moviegoers. It's not a memorable one, that's for sure.

Rating: 3 (out of 5)

Cruella is streaming on Disney+ Hotstar. Watch the trailer here —


by Devki Nehra

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Watch The Sound with Mark Ronson Apple TV+ explores the curious link between music and technology

In The Salmon of Doubt , Douglas Adams writes: “I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary, and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re 15 and 35 is new and exciting and revolutionary, and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're 35 is against the natural order of things.” Cut to the world of music. As much as technology has been a driving force in the industry, the advent of any innovation has often been received with skepticism before it goes on to become the norm. Harnessing that interplay between the creative process of making music and the technological enhancement given to said music, is acclaimed DJ and producer Mark Ronson. In his just-released six-part mini-docuseries Watch the Sound with Mark Ronson , he astutely defines how different the process of creating a great

Studying women presidents and prime ministers on screen, from Meryl Streep in Don't Look Up to Dimple Kapadia in A Thursday

In 2016, when I heard Hillary Clinton had lost the US Presidential race to Donald Trump, I took it as a confirmation that this is how much the US hated its women. And I felt temporarily gratified to live in a country which elected a woman as its third prime minister. This was before I remembered Indira Gandhi was the only woman prime minister we have had, and she was an outlier. Her strong and uncompromising leadership style skews meaningful analysis of gender representation in governance. Anyway, for all the breaking of paths and glass ceilings, trailblazers like Gandhi and Iron Lady Margaret Thatcher commonly belong to conservative or traditional parties. Left to the simultaneously imaginative and mimetic art of comedy, the first woman US president looks like Meryl Streep’s Janine Orlean in Don’t Look Up and Julia Louis Dreyfus’ Selina Meyer in the HBO show Veep . They are both are anti-feminists and women of power. Yet they could not be more different in how they reflect the r

Netflix's Lupin acknowledges dangers of fantasies of omnipotence, introducing viewers to a socially conscious gentleman thief

By Emma Bielecki Netflix’s immensely successful new French-language show Lupin has introduced a new generation of anglophone viewers to one of the most popular characters in French popular fiction, Arsène Lupin, gentleman thief. Lupin was created in 1905 by the writer Maurice Leblanc at the behest of publisher Pierre Lafitte, who had recently launched a general interest magazine, Je Sais Tout . Lafitte wanted a serial that would guarantee a loyal readership for his magazine, as the Sherlock Holmes stories had for the Strand Magazine. Drawing inspiration from Conan Doyle and EW Hornung’s Raffles stories, Leblanc obliged by creating a flamboyant and ultimately always benign trickster figure. Cat burglar, con artist, master of disguise, Lupin is also a brilliant detective and righter of wrongs. His appeal has proved enduring: in addition to the original 20 volumes of stories authored by Leblanc, there have been countless plays, radio shows, TV series and films, from Italian pornos